Lately I hear people say, “What ISIS is doing in the Middle East is terrible…” or others that comment about the sad reality of school shootings in the USA. It is clear that the majority of people believe there is evil in the world. It is interesting to note that when people are saying that an event is bad or wrong they mean that the world ought to be a certain way, or at least not be as it is. C.S Lewis says that the man “who makes the remark is not merely saying that the other man’s behaviour does not happen to please him. He is appealing to some kind of standard of behaviour which he expects the other man to know about... ” (Lewis 15). If he condemns murder then he means the world ought to be a place where no one is murdered. Why do we believe that certain things are good or bad, right or wrong? Where do values or obligations come from? What is the foundation for our morality? This conversation around good or evil leads me to believe in the existence of God, a God who has instilled in people objective moral values and duties.
My argument is:
- If God does not exist, then objective moral values and duties do not exist.
- Objective moral values and duties do exist.
- Therefore, God exists.
Premise 1 - If God does not exist, then objective moral values and duties do not exist.
Two Important Distinctions
Values and Duties: Values have to do with whether something is good or bad. Duties have to do with whether something is right or wrong. Just because something is good doesn’t mean that you are morally obligated to do it. For example, you can become a doctor and that is good but you aren’t morally obligated to become a doctor. Good and bad have to do with the worth of an action or thing while right and wrong has to do with whether something is obligatory or prohibited (Craig 130).
Objective and Subjective: Objective means the truth of something is independent of people’s opinions and subjective means something is true dependent on people’s opinions. So to say that there are objective moral values is to say that something is good or bad no matter what people think. For example, the Nazi anti-Semitism was morally wrong, even though the Nazis thought that it was good and made laws to permit it. (Craig 131).
Is Premise 1 True?:
Objective Moral Values Require God.
Throughout history God has been the basis for objective moral values. God’s holy and good nature provided the standard for all our actions. God is, by nature, loving, generous, just, faithful, kind, to only name a few. But if God doesn’t exist then what is the basis of moral values or human worth? We will now explore how any worldview without a transcendent personal being will fail to create a coherent worldview where objective moral values and duties can exist (Craig n.p.).
The most popular form of atheism is naturalism, which holds that the only things that exist are the things described by our best scientific theories. But science can’t say anything about morality; you can’t find moral values by means of scientific method. It follows that moral values don’t really exist; they are illusions of human beings.
Even if we look beyond science, one of the most popular view is that morals are just products of biological evolution and social conditioning. Humans are the same as monkeys who show collective and self-sacrificial behaviour because natural selection has determined it to be advantageous in the struggle for survival. As a result of sociobiological reasons there has evolved a “herd morality,” similar to brushing one’s teeth, which functions well in the survival and flourishing of humans (Craig 131).
But this doesn’t make this morality objectively true. If one was to rewind history and start again and we may see a whole different set of moral values appear, making our view of morality nothing but the product of societal power struggles. For us to think that human beings are special and our morality objectively true is just speciesism, an unjustified bias toward one’s own species.
In conclusion, if there is no God then we can’t assume that this herd morality is objectively true. As William Lane Craig says in On Guard, “take God out of the picture, and all you’re left with is an apelike creature on a speck of solar dust beset with delusions of moral grandeur” (Craig 132).
Objective Moral Duties Require God
Now looking at moral duties. God’s moral character is expressed to humanity through the means of divine commands which create our moral duties or obligations. These are not arbitrary commands, but these commands flow from God’s nature. These can be summed up in the two great commandments: First, you shall love the Lord your God with all your strength and with all your soul and with all your heart and with all your mind, and, second, you shall love your neighbour as yourself. From this foundation we can affirm the actions of kindness, loyalty, self-sacrifice as objectively right and good and be can do likewise to declare hatred, greed and so on as objectively bad, and wrong (Craig n.p.).
But if there is no God, what basis remains for objective moral duties? Human beings are just complex animals, and animals have no moral obligations to one another. No one arrests a coyote for murdering a bunny. Animals don’t have obligation or prohibitions like humans (Craig 132).
So if God does not exist, why do humans think that we have any objective moral obligations ? Who or what imposes these moral duties upon us? Where do they come from? The voice inside us that tells us that we ought or ought not do certain things is just a subjective impression which has been ingrained in us from societal and parental conditioning.
The implications of this view is that actions like killing and rape are not wrong in of themselves but avoiding these actions are biologically and socially advantageous and therefore over the course of time have become unfashionable or forbidden. This doesn’t prove that they are really wrong. The rapist who goes against this socially created morality is doing nothing but acting against the created societal norms, just like a man farting loudly in public. Without God there are no oughts and no ought nots (Craig 133).
OBJECTIONS:
Here are some objections to this argument:
The Euthyphro Dilemma:
This objection goes like this: Is something good because God wills it? Or does God will something because it is good? If you say that something is good because God wills it, then what is good becomes arbitrary. God could will that mass killing is good, and then we would be morally obligated to follow suit. Yet that seems crazy. But if you say that God wills something because it is good, then what is good or bad is not dependent on God. Moral values and duties therefore exist independently of God, which contradicts premise 1.
This can stump people, but there is a third way: God wills something because He is good. That God’s own nature is the standard of goodness, and His commandments to us are expressions of His nature. Therefore, they’re not arbitrary as they are based necessarily in his character (Craig 135).
Moral Values Simply Exist:
Another attempt to provide another ground for objective moral values and duties is like Plato’s theory that Good just exists on its own as a sort of self-existent idea. Some atheists may say that moral values like justice, mercy, and love just exist without any foundation. Therefore we can conclude that objective moral values exist but are not grounded in God (Craig 137).
Three responses to this theory:
First, one can understand what it means to say that a person is kind, but without personal beings it is hard to understand what kindness is, as an abstract value. It seems like moral values are properties that only make sense in connection to persons and are impossible to understand as just abstract entities.
Second, there is still no basis for moral duties. If moral values like justice, love, mercy just exist then how is it that there are any moral obligations? We don’t know who or what gives people these duties. As well, why don’t we follow the entities of greed, and hatred? How we know to follow a certain list of ideals but not others? This view has no grounds for moral obligations.
Third, it is very improbable that through the random evolutionary process that creatures were created who perfectly meshed with the abstractly existing moral realm. This is an utterly incredible coincidence. One is more reasonable to believe that God’s hand led both the laws of nature and the moral law to its current place where they interact perfectly rather than think that these two independent realms lined up by chance (Craig 138).
Premise 2 - Objective moral values and duties exist.
Is Premise 2 True?:
This may be a controversial notion to hold but most people want to affirm that objective moral values and duties do exist. Through our 5 senses we come to believe in the existence of the physical world, and in the same way we should accept what our moral experience tells us, which is that some things are objectively good or evil, right or wrong.
Most people will recognize that sexual abuse is wrong. Actions like rape, torture, and child abuse are not just taboo but are truly wrong. Although many people hold to relativism being true, people can be convinced of objective moral values and duties. Whether it is priests sexually abusing little children, ISIS killing innocent people, or the Hindu practice of suttee, which burns widows alive with their dead husband. People will agree that these things are wrong (Craig 140).
Often those who want to reject the existence of objective moral values and duties don’t look at the consequences of this worldview in its extreme. If you believe this then you have no grounds to say to all these evil things listed above are really wrong. You could say that from your perspective and your cultural heritage it is wrong but you would have no way of saying that they are wrong objectively. They can just respond by saying, “who are you to say that we are wrong?” As soon as someone starts saying that anything is wrong or right, good or bad, and they don’t have an objective backbone will fail or at least come out weak in their objection.
I believe that all people are aware of moral and immoral behaviour because objective moral values do exist, whether we acknowledge their origin as being from God or not. The Bible says that God’s law is written on our hearts, meaning that we are all aware of an objective moral law above us to which we are accountable to (Steiger 114).
C.S. Lewis states in his book Mere Christianity that throughout history there has been Law of Nature that has crossed all cultures, and all time which points towards the truth of an objective moral standard to which all humans are, to some extent, aware of. He says,
“Think of a country where people were admired for running away in battle, or where a man felt proud of double-crossing all the people who had been kindest to him. You might just as well try to imagine a country where two and two made five. Men have differed as regards what people you ought to be unselfish to - whether it was only your family, or your fellow countrymen, or everyone. But they have always agreed that you ought not to put yourself first. Selfishness has never been admired. Men have differed as to whether you should have one wife or four. But they have always agreed that you must not simply have any woman you liked” (Lewis 17-18).
Lewis also says,
When you “say that one set of moral ideas [is] better than another, you are, in fact, measuring them both by a standard, saying that one of them conforms to that standard more nearly than the other. But the standard that measure two things is something different from either. You are, in fact, comparing them both with some Real Morality, admitting that there is such a thing as a real Right, independent of what people think, and that some people’s ideas get nearer to that real Right than others” (Lewis 23).
This does happen to every human and leads me to believe that each human knows deep down that there is a real Right.
Even non-believers like Michael Ruse support this claim of there being an objective moral law by saying,
“The man who says that it is morally acceptable to rape little children is just as mistaken as the man who says 2+2=5” (Michael 275).
As well the humanist philosopher Peter Cave gives the following example:
“Whatever sceptical arguments may be brought against our belief that killing the innocent is morally wrong, we are more certain that the killing is morally wrong than that the argument is sound. . . . Torturing an innocent child for the sheer fun of it is morally wrong. Full stop” (Peter 146).
People are very aware that child abuse, racial hate, and terrorism are wrong for everybody, always. This is not just a personal preference or opinion!
It seems as if Atheism fails to provide a foundation for the moral reality every one of us experiences every day. In fact, the existence of objective morality points us directly to the existence of God.
In conclusion:
We have found that without a transcendent perfect personal God there is no way objective moral values and duties can exist. Without God we are left in a sea of ambiguity and subjective opinions and our intrinsic compass of good, bad, right and wrong is just an illusion created over time by society and biological evolution. Objective moral truth is unfathomable without God. But, we also have found that we as humans are aware of the truth that there is objective moral values and duties. It concludes that God must exist if both of our premises are true; it follows then that we must adopt this worldview if we are to hold true to an integral pursuit of truth.
Work Cited
Craig, William Lane, Dr. "Can We Be Good without God? | Reasonable Faith." "The Moral Argument | Reasonable Faith." "Transcript: The Moral Argument." "Justification of the Moral Argument’s Second Premiss." ReasonableFaith.org. ReasonableFaith, n.d. Web. 05 Dec. 2015.
Craig, William Lane. On Guard: Defending Your Faith with Reason and Precision. Colorado Springs, CO: David C. Cook, 2010. Print.
Steiger, Andy, and Sheri Hiebert. Thinking?: Answering Life's Five Biggest Questions. Apologetics Canada Publishing. 2015. Print.
Keller, Timothy. The Reason for God: Belief in an Age of Skepticism. New York: Dutton, 2008. Print.
"Sam Harris vs William Lane Craig - The Foundation Of Morality - 2011."YouTube. YouTube, n.d. Web. 05 Dec. 2015.
"Is God Necessary for Morality? William Lane Craig vs Shelly Kagan Debate."YouTube. YouTube, n.d. Web. 05 Dec. 2015.
Lewis, C. S. Mere Christianity. New York: MacMillan Pub., 1952. Print.
Michael Ruse, Darwinism Defended (London: Addison-Wesley, 1982), p. 275.
Peter Cave, Humanism (Oxford: OneWorld, 2009), p. 146. Thanks to Peter S. Williams for this reference.



No comments:
Post a Comment