Thursday, 12 November 2015

No-See-Um's

I recently read an article written by Sam Harris (author and neuroscientist) redefining atheism and disproving God’s existences. His argument: the problem of evil. Harris in his article affirms the reality of evil by brings up several issues: child rape, natural disaster, and human massacre by means of trampling. He states that this reality is inconsistent with the Christian all-good, all-knowing, all-powerful God. Either God is good and is not powerful enough to stop the evil or he is powerful but he chooses not to stop the evil, making him not all-good. Both of these options lead us to the conclusion that the classic notion of the Christian God is nonsense and must be disregarded in order to face reality and start living an enlightened life.
   
There are two things that I will address.
  1. Harris’ definition of Atheism.
  2. Harris’ use of the problem of evil.


First, Harris claims that atheism is not a belief system or a worldview and therefore doesn't need to give evidence for their non-belief in God. He believes the idea of God is so silly and unnecessary that he doesn't need to hold proof for his lack of belief. This excuses him from the burden of proof. My response to this is that in the pursuit of truth we all have different claims that come our way and we assess these beliefs and either reject them or we accept them. So if this claim of God’s existence comes with some serious evidence then it would be irresponsible to just reject this idea right away because of how unnecessary or silly you think it is. As seekers of truth we must study other religions and worldviews in hopes that we will come closer to the truth about reality. Now, once they either reject or accept this claim they must have reasons for this conclusion or they are the silly ones whose worldview has no foundation.


Second, To Harris it seems that belief in a good, all-knowing, all-powerful God is ridiculous “given the relentless destruction of innocent human beings we witness in the world each day.” He holds two presuppositions.
First, he presupposes that evil does exist, that the world ought not be a certain way which leads us to the question how should the world be? What is good? What is his standard for goodness? It seems like his only answer to this is in naming things that he just knows, “in his bones”, are wrong for humanities flourishment and survival. He states that hurricanes, child rape, mass death ought not happen, and is therefore wrong. This is a very vague definition of good and is very subjective in nature.    
Second, he asserts that if God is good then there couldn’t possibly be the amount of evil that there is but in this assertion lies a hidden premise, namely, “that if evil appears pointless to me, then it must be pointless.... [This is just false and] is illustrated well by the “no-see-ums” illustration of Alvin Plantinga. If you look into your pup tent for a St. Bernard, and you don’t see one, it is reasonable to assume that there is no St. Bernard in your tent. But if you look into your pup tent for a “no-see-um” (an extremely small insect) and you don’t see any, it is not reasonable to assume they aren’t there. Because, after all, no one can see ‘em. Many assume that if there were good reasons for the existence of evil, they would be accessible to our minds, more like St. Bernards than like no-see-ums, but why should that be the case?” (Keller, Reason For God, 23).
Christianity is the belief system that doesn’t gloss over the depth of the world's suffering but has resources to engage in it and find hope amidst it. At the core of the Christian faith is God, with skin on, coming into our messy world, being a victim of human cruelty, and ultimately dying on the cross to redeem us from the powers of death, and evil. Harris is wrong in saying that Christians have a shallow view of evil and that people free from God’s influence somehow have a more sober look on reality. Christianity doesn’t make us run from evil and suffering but allows us to engage in it fully with the hope that our creator faced trials and paved us a way to new life and hope for a new kingdom and future without the corruption that our world experiences now.



No comments:

Post a Comment